# Three Equivalent Conditions for an Ideal is Prime in a PID

## Problem 724

Let $R$ be a principal ideal domain. Let $a\in R$ be a nonzero, non-unit element. Show that the following are equivalent.

(1) The ideal $(a)$ generated by $a$ is maximal.

(2) The ideal $(a)$ is prime.

(3) The element $a$ is irreducible.

## Proof.

### (1) $\implies$ (2)

Note that the ideal $(a)$ is maximal if and only if $R/(a)$ is a field. In particular $R/(a)$ is a domain and hence $(a)$ is a prime ideal.

(Note that this is true without assuming $R$ is a PID.)

### (2) $\implies$ (3)

Now suppose that the ideal $(a)$ is prime.

Let $a=bc$ for some elements $b, c \in R$. Then the element $a=bc$ is in the prime ideal $(a)$, and thus we have either $b$ or $c$ is in $(a)$. Without loss of generality, we assume that $b\in (a)$.

Then we have $b=ad$ for some $d\in R$. It follows that we have

\[a=bc=adc\]
and since $R$ is a domain, we have

\[1=dc\]
and hence $c$ is a unit. Therefore the element $a$ is irreducible.

### (3) $\implies$ (1)

Suppose that $a$ is an irreducible element.

Let $I$ be an ideal of $R$ such that

\[(a) \subset I \subset R.\]

Since $R$ is a PID, there exists $b\in R$ such that $I=(b)$.

Then since $(a)\subset (b)$, we have $a=bc$ for some $c\in R$.

The irreducibility of $a$ implies that either $b$ or $c$ is a unit.

If $b$ is a unit, then we have $I=R$. If $c$ is a unit, then we have $(a)=I$.

Therefore the ideal $(a)$ is maximal.

Add to solve later

Sponsored Links